The Dollmaker of Krakow review by NatsustayHappy
The Dollmaker of Krakow
by R. M. Romero
Age Range - 8 - 12
Genre - Adventure

Student Review

Profile Picture
Age at time of review - 13
Reviewer's Location - Guys Mills, PA, United States
View NatsustayHappy's profile

The Dollmaker of Krakow begins with a little doll called Karolina, who has a heart made of glass. Karolina comes from the Land of Dolls, a place of powdered sugar snow and gingerbread houses: a place full of magic. But when war comes to the Land of Dolls, rats force Karolina to leave her peaceful home where she would make clothes for all her friends, sewing their wishes into the hems.

Karolina is found by a kind wind who takes Karolina and her friend, Fritz, to the human world, placing them in the hands of two different magicians. Karolina wakes to find herself in the humble toy shop of the Dollmaker, who soon becomes her best and closest friend. But all around Krakow, the Dollmaker's home, war has also come, bringing harsh and hostile Germans with it. Karolina and the Dollmaker are forced to watch as their beautiful Krakow is taken over by Hitler and his German soldiers.

The Dollmaker and Karolina soon become very concerned for their Jewish friends, Rena and her father Jozef Trzmiel, the violinist. Quickly the Trzmiel family of two are taken away by the Germans to a ghetto with other Jews from Krakow. The Dollmaker and Karolina hatch a brilliant, yet extremely risky plan to get their friends to safety- but it will mean taking lots of risks, channeling the Dollmaker's magic, and needing a bit of help from their enemy, Brandt, a fellow, yet evil, magician. Despite these dangers, Dollmaker and Karolina are willing to take those risks if it means finding safety for their friends- even if it costs them their lives.


The story of The Dollmaker of Krakow is sweet yet hostile, filled with war and magic, and not-so-happy endings. I have to admit, halfway through the story I was getting a little bored and ready to move on, but in the end, R. M. Romero really pulled through, grabbing my attention and making me speed on to the last chapters.

My heart broke while reading about Karolina and the Dollmaker's best friends, Rena and Jozef, and the terrible things that they and their fellow Jews were put through. Although the story had a slow start, I'm glad I continued to read The Dollmaker of Krakow, because the ending really brought tears to my eyes. I am very thankful to R. M. Romero for showing me, and you, the story she crafted, just as the Dollmaker crafted Karolina. I hope that you will enjoy the book as much as I did. 

Content Rating:

Content rating - some mature content

Explain your content rating: 

There are multiple instances where the Germans are called 'witches'. There is also a moment when a little boy violently crushes a pet mouse (but don't worry- all is fixed with poor Mytz). In one chapter, a butterfly's wing gets ripped, and then the butterfly is changed into a spider, and back again, but his wing is repaired. There is also a violent scene where a man's hands are bashed and broken with a hammer, and a scene when a girl's arm is chewed off by a dog. There are also multiple scenes of hatred towards the Jews, where they are thrown, hit, and forced to work against their will, but over-all nothing is described in explicit detail.




Read more reviews by Litpick Student Book Reviewer: NatsustayHappy
Recommend this book and review to your friends on Facebook

Students improve reading & writing
Authors get reviews, videos, social media, & more
Find great books and start book clubs too!